In The Science Fair Switch, a middle grade STEM mystery by Claire Bennett, twelve-year-old Marisol “Mari” Vega walks up to her science fair table and finds bean seedlings where her model sidewalks should be. The beans belong to Theo Bell. The projects are in the wrong spots, but that’s the easy part to explain. The scores are another matter.
Mari built two miniature sidewalks to test how much water runs off each surface. Theo wanted to see how light affects the growth of bean seedlings. Their projects don’t have much in common until the Bellwether Middle science fair gives them a question neither one planned to investigate.
Mari gained points. Theo lost them. But the numbers weren’t swapped.
Mari’s score went from eight to eleven. Theo’s went down. If the judges had simply scored the wrong projects, switching the numbers back ought to make everything line up. It doesn’t.
So Mari and Theo compare their judging slips and look more closely at a photo taken during setup. That’s where readers get a chance to investigate alongside them. What can a picture tell you about where a project was? What can it tell you about when it moved? And how much would you be willing to say about who moved it?
A good clue can still lead to a bad guess
When a shared photo casts suspicion in the wrong direction, Mari has to examine more than the judging slips. She’s good at spotting when someone else’s explanation doesn’t fit. It’s harder to notice when she’s doing the same thing herself, especially when she wants the fair to set things right.
That’s what makes the science fair more than a backdrop. Mari knows how to compare two surfaces without jumping to conclusions about her results. Applying that same care to a picture of another person, when classmates are already talking, takes a different kind of patience.
The Science Fair Switch is a standalone pick for sixth-grade readers who like realistic school mysteries, hands-on projects, and clues they can test against their own theories. It also gives a classroom or book club a question to try before the ending. If your score went up and your friend’s went down, would you question the result as quickly as you would if it were the other way around?
